So...take a look at your strategic plan. Is the truth in there, or does it contain elements you added strictly for PR purposes? Why would you be willing to pay the price for something like this?
Tuesday, October 08, 2013
What you mean vs. what you say in your strategic plan
So...take a look at your strategic plan. Is the truth in there, or does it contain elements you added strictly for PR purposes? Why would you be willing to pay the price for something like this?
Sunday, August 25, 2013
Would you prefer sales growth or profit growth?
Monday, June 24, 2013
Are you REALLY doing strategic planning?
Subject is what you are really talking about when you are doing strategic planning. As I said in my books, there are three questions that we ask in strategy - and if the subject isn't about one of these three questions, you aren't being strategic. The questions are:
- What do we do?
- For whom do we do it?
- How do we beat (or better, avoid) competition?
Focus is not, as most assume, about what you are going to do. That's too easy. Focus is about what you WON'T do. With proper focus, you can tell the world who you are and they will look to you to deliver on the things that make you outstanding. The hard part is giving up the things you are NOT focusing on. Strategic planning is not about what you should do, want to do or could do - it is about what you must do to succeed in a focused target area.
Execution is actually doing what you plan to do. It's easy to say "we will go here and do this" - it's another thing entirely to DO it. If you put little or not effort into your execution, you may have great strategy, but you will have disappointing results.
Does your organization do all of these things well in strategic planning? Which of the three do you find the biggest challenge?
Sunday, February 10, 2013
Video - How to Set and Reach Your Objectives
http://www.strategyspeakers.com/robert_bradford.php
Tuesday, February 05, 2013
What is strategic planning?
-SWOT analysis
-A list of objectives
-A book prepared for your board of directors
-Budgeting
-A nice looking document that no one looks at after completion
-A balanced scorecard
-A mission statement
Strategic planning is a process of setting the course and direction for an organization or other endeavor. A well done strategic plan focuses the resources of the endeavor on those activities which will yield the best results. For businesses, this means optimizing profitability, survive-ability and growth-ability.
The best way to assess the quality of a strategic plan is to ask these questions:
-What did you do as a result of the plan?
-What difference did it make for your organization?
Considering the answers to these questions, how would you improve YOUR strategic planning?
Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Upstream and Downstream
I like to closely examine any ideas this may spark about win-win activities that might involve the upstream or downstream players. A good example would be a social networking site which encourages you to invite friends - you are helping them by growing their network, and helping yourself by expanding the network you can draw upon within that site. This particular win-win activity goes a long way to explain the rapid growth of social networks as both a business and recreational tool.
Question to ask in your strategic planning: What activities might you encourage that create a similar win-win situation for your upstream and downstream stakeholders?
Wednesday, January 02, 2013
Starting the year right
One of the best ways to assure your company has a good year is to have a concrete, documented strategic planning process. Ideally, your strategic planning should occur during a time when it will have less impact on your routine operations, but the key point is that you actually schedule and hold strategic planning meetings. To minimize conflict and schedule issues, it's also a good idea to plan your meetings one or two months in advance, and possible even longer if your team has difficult travel schedules. I've found that you will get a lot more out of your team if you hold your planning meeting off-site and work with a professional strategic planner who is not going to try to use the process to sell you other consulting. If you can afford to get your team out of town to a nice destination, it is definitely worth the effort, as your team will look forward to the process and view strategic planning as something to look forward to. Start your year off well by scheduling your strategic planning this week!
Friday, October 12, 2012
What does a "Real" Strategic Plan look like?
1. A "real" strategic plan is verbose.
Or long. Or written out like an article or a book. This is one of the most common errors - and one of the stupidest. Think about the last time you REALLY planned something. Did you write an article? No. You probably wrote yourself a checklist. Why? Because that's how we get things done. When was the last time you picked up a wordy article and said to yourself "Wow, I have to do this..."?
2. A "real" strategic plan is overloaded with details and financial targets.
This is a sneaky one. When people put lots of numbers in a strategic plan, it creates the illusion that they have a better plan. But think about this - what do you REALLY know about those numbers? Where did they come from? I have seen companies with very, very detailed financial plans get in trouble because they focus more attention on their predictions than on the underlying strategic realities. Strategic plans exist in the real world, where sales forecasts are almost always wrong and any number you predict in the future is highly suspect. Instead of putting all that work into quantifying the unquantifiable, perhaps you should spend a little more time on realistic systems thinking about the nature of your industry, and how it is likely to change in the next few years. Making your assumption a number will not make it a fact.
3. A "real" strategic plan is insanely short.
I like some of the thinking behind this one. Making your plan short does force you to focus on the reality behind your planning. But just as one can put too much detail into a plan, you can also put in too little. An effective strategic plan has enough detail to be useful, but not so much that it gets in the way of understanding - AND ACTING ON - your strategic thinking.
4. A "real" strategic plan doesn't have implementation steps.
If all you want from a plan is a pretty document. bless your heart. If, like most executives I work with, you actually want RESULTS from your strategic planning, you must have some detail and accountability on the implementation of your strategies. If you don't, your plan will be - at best - a very clever documentation of your thinking, rather than a tool to get results.
Have you encountered any of these errors? Does your company's strategic plan show signs of them? Using the Simplified Strategic Planning process can greatly improve the usability and effectiveness of your plan. Be sure to check out our popular and long-running seminar series (https://www.cssp.com/seminars) for detailed, step-by-step instructions on how to create a strategic plan that truly delivers results.
Wednesday, May 04, 2011
Is Retail Strategy different from other strategy?
When I do public strategic planning programs for a broad audience, I am sometimes asked “Is strategic planning for a retail business different from strategic planning for a different kind of business, such as a manufacturer?” The answer, not surprisingly, is “yes AND no”. The differences and similarities may surprise you.
To begin with, the “product” of a retail store is different from most product and service creating businesses in that it is not part of a discrete transaction conducted with the customer – that is, as a retailer, you do not get a separate payment from your customer for the value you produce. Instead, you always (or almost always) make money on payments from your customers for goods and/or services produced by others. Of course, there are exceptions – for example, if you do food preparation on your premises, you are getting paid directly for that value – but in most cases, retailers make their money on the markup on the goods and/or services they are selling.
To put a finer point on this distinction, as a retailer you get some compensation from customers – largely for the experience you generate around their purchase – and some compensation from suppliers – largely for the infrastructure you provide for their distribution. How much compensation comes from either source is a tangled topic we can address elsewhere, but the point is, you make your money as a retailer by providing infrastructure and experience.
And here is one place where strategic planning for retailers is just like strategy done for anyone else: as a rule, the more easily a service/product can be measured and duplicated, the harder it is to sell it as a specialty. In retail, the value of infrastructure is exactly that – something that is easily measured and duplicated. This is not always so – a huge distribution network like Wal-Mart’s is hard to duplicate, and so is a highly specialized semi-monopoly network like Duty Free America. Still, for most suppliers, access to customers through one infrastructure network is pretty much the same as the others. For customers, however, the differences can be notable and – in the eye of the customer – worth quite a bit.
If you run a retail business, where do your stores stand? Do you sell an experience or infrastructure? How does your strategic competency add to your uniqueness and the value you create for your customers?
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Strategic Vision at Apple: Will it change under Tim Cook?
First, many credit Jobs' vision for the success of Apple. In some ways, this is not far off the mark - Jobs, especially after his return to Apple in 1998, pushed Apple in some weird directions that clearly distinguished the tech company from its competitors. Probably the best part of this strategy was an emphasis on design and a willingness to take a shot at unusual new products before it was clear consumers wanted to buy them.
The first item - emphasis on design - could arguably be Apple's strategic competency. Every successful Apple product has had a design that notably distinguishes it from competitors, and in most cases, the Apple product has re-defined its market.
The second item - a willingness to take risks on new products - lies at the heart of entrepreneurial success in any industry, and is only notable at Apple because size tends to extinguish this vital recklessness. The Fortune 500 is littered with companies that used to have this gambling mentality - but no longer do. Apple still has it, and one could argue this is because of Jobs.
Enter Tim Cook - a perennial number two, according to some, Cook has been seen as an operations guy - and a brilliant one with a keen mind. Operations, unlike design and marketing, does not often reward entrepreneurial recklessness, though - so will Cook bring a vision that can sustain Apple's weird status in the future? On the one hand, people who know Cook say he is a great strategic thinker. On the other hand, operational responsibilities can infect your mind with a gray practicality that deadens the innovative spirit of an organization. It's truly too soon to tell, but don't bet on Apple going dead in the water immediately. Cook knows he has a lot of very keen people around him who have been part of Apple's success over the past ten years - and he is smart enough to know how to work with them. Let's hope he doesn't try to "re-make" Apple in his image just to satisfy his ego - any sign of that would be the kiss of death, as it has been for countless other successful companies in transition.
Monday, February 07, 2011
Why Wal-Mart is not invincible
While I'm not a big fan of commodity strategies in general, so much has been made of Wal-Mart's management approach that I will find future developments in this market space very interesting to watch.
Here is a question for you in your strategic planning: Are YOU staying on top of your game? Are you considering pursuit of strategic moves that may create chinks in your armor? And how are you preparing yourself for a better 2011 and beyond?
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
Making things matter
Friday, December 03, 2010
Strategic Planning: The "disappearing middle" of the job market
An article in The Lookout on Yahoo notes that there is a "disappearing middle" in the job market. This trend - growth in lower-tier unskilled jobs and upper-tier skilled jobs, looks suspiciously like the "saddle curve" we use to explain the profit impact of pursuing specialty and commodity strategies. Is is possible that the labor market is now coming to reflect the same specialty and commodity tendencies we have observed in other markets? An interesting question is: why has this tendency not been apparent in the past? Strategically, you should ask yourself: is my company employing specialty employees or commodity employees - and how does that fit with our strategic planning?
Monday, June 14, 2010
Help! I can't get my team thinking strategically!

This is a cry for help I get a few times a year. Fortunately, I'm good at fixing this problem. Of course, you are wondering how.
Here are four simple tips for getting a team to think more strategically:
1. Force thinking to the future. The more distant future brings up questions about the survival of the industry, not just your company.
2. Ask why we exist. Not how are we going to exist, but why.
3. Use strategic imagery. Don't talk about swimming faster - talk about swimming in the right direction.
4. Challenge the team to make their own luck. Get them thinking about how to get your company doing the right thing, in the right place, at the right time.
5. Every time someone suggests a tactical solution, respond negatively: "That's only going to make us a little more successful next year. I want something bigger".
If these don't work - or if they do, for that matter - you should seriously consider bringing in a professional who focuses on challenging teams to think more strategically. Drop me a line and I'll tell you how to get me to come do it in person.
Tuesday, May 11, 2010
Strategic Planning: Why Wal-Mart is a bad place to buy books
Wal-Mart wants to turn over its merchandise quickly, and prices hot items (like the Nintendo Wii) to sell quickly. When it comes to books, there is a serious problem in this. Wal-Mart has been having a price war with Amazon over best-selling titles. Fortunately for Amazon, Wal-Mart has to do this, because Wal-Mart would never win a value war with Amazon. Amazon has invested huge amounts in having millions of titles available - arguably, a better selection of books than any other source on the planet. Wal-Mart - true to their commodity strategy - only wants to sell huge quantities of the best-selling books. This means that Wal-Mart, at best, might carry one thousand titles, compared to Amazon's millions. This brings us to the classic reason to buy - or not buy - from Wal-Mart. Want a cheap price on a New York Times bestseller? Wal-Mart will probably have it, and they will try to price it less than Amazon. This is still a challenge, since Wal-Mart is still largely a bricks-and-mortar operation, but their advanced distribution and purchasing power enables them to give Amazon a run for it's money.
But let's look at the flip side: Want any one of a million titles - say, a book about fossil hunting in Florida? Wal-Mart will never carry such a title, because the turnover rate would be too poor. In fact, there are thousands of books in a typical Borders or Barnes and Noble that Wal-Mart wouldn't want to carry because they don't have the volume demand that, say, the latest Twilight book would have. This approach might make little difference to readers who only buy a book or two to take to the beach in the summer - which is a valid, addressable market that Wal-Mart already caters to - but it makes buying books at Wal-Mart about the same as buying clothing at a convenience store. Sure, you might find what you are looking for, but you'll waste a lot less time going to a specialty retailer whose strategy is centered on giving you the selection you want. This is true whether you are talking about online sales or bricks-and-mortar sales: selection is both a cost and a consumer preference in the book market (and arguably, the fashion market and many others).
Wal-Mart can succeed by sacrificing the preference for selection because price is also a strong preference. For retailers like Amazon, however, the strategy of leaning into Wal-Mart's weakness (product selection) will always garner a sizeable chunk of market share. The challenge for even more specialty-oriented stores (small, independent booksellers, for example) is to provide other values that Amazon (or Waldenbooks) won't, such as personal service, focused selection, ambiance, and browsing configurations.
I'd go a step beyond this and say that people who buy books at Wal-Mart are also doing society a disservice, because civilization suffers when economic resources are diverted only to cultural production that sells in mass quantities, but that's a somewhat elitist viewpoint. Still, a culture that only supports best-sellers isn't just bland, it is systematically likely to sink to the lowest common denominator in literature. Call me a snob, but I'd prefer not to build a civilization on Harlequin romances.
How about your business? Are you like a Wal-Mart, an Amazon, or a small independent bookstore? How do you create value for your customers? Does your strategic planning give you the ability to out-serve your biggest competitors in a huge portion of your market?
Friday, October 30, 2009
The State of the Art
In times of economic turmoil - or even just turmoil in a specific industry - many companies turn away from their strategic planning to focus on short-term issues. In many cases this is warranted - your course may not be as important if the ship is sinking - but in far more cases, this departure can lead to bad strategy and failure.
One of the best (and to me, the most painful) examples of this departure from the path of good strategy occurred at Disney from 2001 to 2008. In the years before this - from 1991 to 2001 - Disney operated an excellent park at Disney World called Pleasure Island. This park filled in an important gap for both families and convention attendees in the area - the absence of nightlife for adults. While this fell outside the Disney strategic competency of family entertainment (viewed on its own), it was well within that competency when seen as a part of the bigger picture, answering the question "How can we keep the whole family happy during a week at Disney World?". Unlike any other place in the world, Pleasure Island offered (during its peak years) family oriented nightlife - a place where I wouldn't mind taking my young children to go dancing or take in a comedy show.
In 2001, the aftermath of 9/11 devastated the travel industry, and hit Disney hard. To overcome this, Pleasure Island management started targeting the local nightclub crowd, making changes to the operation that made it more appealing to young local people. This change may have decreased losses in 2001-2002, but it also decreased the family appeal of the attraction, and Pleasure Island started to fade as a part of the Disney destination as it became more of a local hang-out spot. As you might expect, the very non-family oriented problems of nightclubs - drugs, violence, gangs - also seemed to be increasing during this time. Attendance -especially by families and Disney vacation-goers- declined steadily as the Pleasure Island operation became less of a distinct entity and more of an imitation of Citywalk at Universal Studios nearby.
In 2008, the entire operation was shut down, to make room for more shops in the Downtown Disney area. Thus, a unique part of the strategic competency of Disney World suffered a strategic loss due to changes that were made for tactical reasons seven years before.
While the decisions involved in the decline of Pleasure Island may well have been made in strategic planning, there was a clear departure from strategic competency-based thinking for more tactical considerations of short-term revenue enhancement in 2001-2002. Small changes, like the cessation of fireworks and live shows, and big changes, like the removal of admission gates from the island entrance, led very directly to the decline and, ultimately, the failure of the operation.
Has your company departed from its strategy in the past year? Do you need to return to strategic competency-based planning to renew the true distinction that your company can have in the marketplace? Now would be a good time to consider returning to a discipline of formal strategic planning to assure success not just next year, but for years to come.
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
When Should You Get on the Bandwagon?

You have no doubt seen many of the indicators that the recession may soon be over (if it isn't already, a view held by some very smart economists). This doesn't mean everything will return to the rosy days of, say, 2006, but it does mean the economy will begin growing again. With this knowledge, you are probably thinking about when you should consider revving up the profit engine in your company. The timing of this can be a critical question in many industries.
As a general rule, you don't want to rev up too early, because you will increase your expenses to do so, and profitability will suffer as you spend on capacity that you do not need. On the other hand, you also don't want to rev up too late, because this could easily lead to a loss of market share as your inability to fill orders in the short term pulls you up short. A more difficult and probable effect of undercapacity is that parts of your distribution channel - and even individual customers - are likely to switch to competitors when you cannot meet their needs.
These two factors push against each other - the risk of increasing expenses too early tempers your desire to reduce the risk of losing market share in a recovery. Obviously, excellent forecasting - or at least close attention to real economic data - can be very valuable to you here. Beyond timing your return to expansion precisely, you should also assess the real risks of both scenarios. If you are pursuing commodity strategies, the cost of increasing costs too soon may be unbearable with your super-lean cost structure. On the other hand, a specialty strategy may lead you to see the cost issue as small compared to the risk of losing market share, especially when some market share loss may be permanent.
How should you handle this in your strategic planning? An objective look at your current financial model and market position should be a part of at least some of your monthly strategy implementation review meetings. Until we have passed the current economic inflection point, you will be well-served to look at the upside AND downside of both increasing costs and losing market share.
Thursday, May 14, 2009
Strategic Planning - Better Business Models, part 2
The quintessential example of failure on this point is one of the oldest ways to create a scam – sell someone on the idea that they can get lots of money, quickly, without special skills or hard work. Sometimes these scams are simple (the Nigerian 401 scam), while sometimes they are grand and complex (Bernie Madoff and Enron come to mind). The fundamental nature of free market capitalism – that it is an engine of creative destruction – means that ANY business model that requires little work, skill, risk or time will be destroyed as quickly as competitors figure it out. Incidentally, if you think through the implications of each of these advantages (little work, little skill, little risk and little time), it becomes quite clear that business models built on top of genuine strategic competency are the only ones that have a long-term chance of success.
Tuesday, May 05, 2009
Strategic Planning for Acquisitions - Team Composition

When you are evaluating an acquisition, who should be on your team? As a general rule, you should attempt to include anyone who has primary responsibility for an area affected by the acquisition. For example, if operations will be affected (and they almost always are), you will want to include the VP of Operations. Obviously, there are a few other areas that are always - or almost always - affected by an acquisition, which means that most (if not all) companies will also want the CEO, the CFO and the VP of Sales involved. If you have a VP of marketing with a strategic level of responsibility, he or she would also be a good addition to the team. In many companies, you will also want to consider including the heads of IT, Human Resources, and Technology/Engineering - depending on your industry, and the ability of the person in question to think strategically about the acquisition.
I'd be curious to hear if there are people you have included in acquisition teams in the past that aren't listed here. Do you have any experiences (good or bad) that might suggest ways you should consider team composition? Let me know!
Thursday, April 30, 2009
Strategic Planning: How to RE-think Your Business Model
I do have to question the wisdom of tackling this for the first time in a recession, though - and here's why: tuning up a business model requires good information from the market.
The information from the market right now suggests (for example) that US consumers only want to buy 6 million vehicles a year. This is obviously poppycock, as anyone in the auto industry could tell you - but behaviors change during a recession.
When you are re-designing your business model, you are trying to create a structure that will work for you ALL the time - in both good times and bad. In many cases, the best business models simply don't work that well during a recession - so you have to structure your business to weather the storm.
All this being said, some markets may be changing so fundamentally that it would be suicidal NOT to re-examine your business model. So what is the best process for doing this?
In strategic planning, the business model is often one of the core strategic issues, so I often find myself tinkering with it.
In the past 20 years, I've found myself making excellent changes - and sometimes not so excellent ones. Here are a few things I've learned from the hundreds of times I've tackled this:
1. Build your model on DATA, not emotion
2. Understand ALL FLOWS in your model - not just the easy ones
3. Start with an understanding of your STRATEGIC COMPETENCY
4. Looking at your current model, ask WHY and WHY NOT about every area where customer value is not optimized
5. Pay close attention to the things EVERYONE IS DOING - and figure out how to avoid them
6. When you have a new model you like, SHOOT HOLES IN IT - and then fix them
7. Make sure you have a good EXECUTION PLAN for making sure the model changes - you will meet resistance!
My next few posts will be about each of these points, and some of the things I do to assure the output is a sturdy, viable business model.